An Ode to the Upper West Side: My Favorite Local Eats

by

You found our guide on places to eat on the Upper West Side!

An Ode to the Upper West Side: My Favorite Local Eats

After three years of living on the Upper West Side, I definitely hesitate to call myself a local—but I think it’s safe to say I’ve gotten to know the neighborhood a bit. Through quiet walks home from work and lazy weekend wanders, I’ve slowly fallen for this classic, cozy corner of the city. I’ve found my favorite routes, my go-to treats, and, most importantly, the food spots I keep coming back to.

Because to me, the best way to get to know any place—especially New York—is through its food. And the UWS doesn’t disappoint.

Upper West Siders carry a unique kind of pride. It’s not flashy or fast-paced, but deeply rooted, loyal, and full of neighborhood love. So, as someone who’s learned to love it too, here’s my little ode to this wonderful neighborhood—through the places that have fed me, literally and otherwise.

This article includes:

  • best restaurants upper west side
  • upper west side
  • halal cart
  • best pizza near me
  • best bagels near me

Interested in more neighborhood recommendations? Check out 15 Things to Do on the Upper West Side, NYC: The Perfect Itinerary.

Here at sundays, we believe in embracing balance—whether it’s a nourishing meal, a moment of stillness, or a little joy in your day. We’re proud to be part of a city filled with passionate, hard-working small businesses, and we love celebrating the neighborhood gems that make New York feel like home. Just like our non-toxic approach to beauty, these spots are rooted in care, intention, and community.

Long story short, here is a list of my favorite places to grab a bite on the Upper West Side!

10 Must-Visit Foods Spots on the Upper West Side:

1. Zabar’s (Broadway & 80th)

The definition of a New York institution. Zabar’s is more than a Jewish deli—it’s a cultural hub, a community hangout, and one of the last places in the city that truly feels like home.

Must-gets:

  • Freshly ground coffee (Kenya and Kona blends are personal favorites)

  • Nova (fresh-cut smoked salmon perfection)

  • Rugelach straight from the counter

  • Their under-the-radar chocolate chip cookies

If you’re lucky, you might spot Saul Zabar himself, still making his rounds in his signature Zabar’s coat. You can feel the heart and history the second you walk in.

Check out Zabar’s.

coffee beans

2. Milano Market (Broadway & 112th)

Technically Morningside Heights, but worth the few extra blocks. This Italian deli is my not-so-secret secret.

Go-to order:

  • E9 sandwich. Just trust me.

  • Also home to one of the best chicken Caesar salads around.

The guys behind the counter know what they’re doing—there’s nothing on the menu that won’t satisfy.

Check out Milano Market.

3. Broadnosh Bagels (Broadway & 85th)

This place changed the way I feel about BECs (bacon, egg, and cheese).

My order:

  • BEC on an everything or French toast bagel (yes, French toast bagel)

  • Skip the salt & pepper—still perfect

The line might be long, but it’s worth the wait. And pro tip: keep track of your ticket number—respect the bagel system!

Check out Broadnosh.

4. The Hungarian Pastry Shop (Amsterdam & 110th)

A UWS gem and maybe my favorite spot on this list. Great coffee, even better pastries, and an unbeatable atmosphere.

Must-gets:

  • Poppy seed strudel

  • Almond croissant

  • Order a full cake with mixed slices for special occasions

Popular with Columbia students and creatives alike—it’s the perfect spot to write, read, or just sit and watch the world go by.

Check out The Hungarian Pastry Shop.

5. V&T’s (Amsterdam & 110th)

Right next door to Hungarian and a neighborhood classic. This old-school Italian joint has been around for over 70 years for a reason—solid pizza and no-frills comfort.

Check out V&T’s.

6. Mama’s TOO! (Broadway & 105th)

If you’re craving pizza that’s not your classic NYC slice, this is the spot. Mama’s TOO! has bold, inventive flavors and a crust you’ll think about for days.

Check out Mama’s TOO!.

7. Koronet Pizza (Broadway & 110th)

Okay, last pizza recommendation—promise. You haven’t seen a slice until you’ve seen a Koronet slice.

Get the vodka sauce slice. Trust me.

Check out Koronet Pizza.

8. Sala Thai (Amsterdam & 74th)

Craving Thai? This is your spot. Cozy, flavorful, and always hits the mark.

Must-gets:

  • Mango sticky rice

  • Kha nom jeeb (steamed dumplings)

  • Thai iced tea

They’ve also got a solid cocktail list for those staying a little longer.

Check out Sala Thai.

9. Kikoo Sushi (Columbus & 110th)

A relaxed go-to for solid sushi and low-key vibes. Great for a casual weeknight dinner or a laid-back date.

My order:

  • Three-roll combo: salmon avocado, spicy tuna, spicy yellowtail with jalapeño

  • Don’t forget the edamame

Check out Kikoo.

10. Hooda Halal (Broadway & 110th)

Last but never least—my favorite halal cart in the city. It’s a constant in my ever-changing routine.

Go-to:

  • Chicken over rice with white sauce and BBQ sauce (sub red sauce if I’m feeling bold)

  • The fries in the combo make it extra special

  • The guys behind the cart are awesome—say hi if you can!

Check out Hooda Halal.

Final Thoughts

Sure, not everything on this list is the “healthiest” choice—but food is about balance, comfort, and connection. These are the spots that have shaped my relationship with this neighborhood, and they’re part of what makes the Upper West Side feel like home.

Whether you live nearby or you’re just visiting, I hope this guide inspires a few delicious detours. And even if you’re not on the UWS, many of these places have locations around the city—so keep your eyes peeled.

Here’s to finding your place, one bite at a time.

Next, check out SoHo Shopping Guide: A Curated Experience for the Stylish & Wellness-Conscious Woman.

more from sundays:

FAQ: An Ode to the Upper West Side: My Favorite Local Eats

Here are some frequently asked questions about restaurants UWS!

1. Are these spots good for first-time visitors to the Upper West Side?

Absolutely. Each place on this list offers something special—whether it’s iconic like Zabar’s, low-key like Kikoo Sushi, or classic like V&T’s. They’re welcoming, casual, and perfect for getting a feel for the neighborhood’s spirit.

2. Are there healthier options in the neighborhood?

Definitely! While this list leans comfort-forward, the UWS has plenty of health-conscious cafes, salad spots, and juice bars. (Happy to share those next!) But I believe balance is key—and sometimes the best way to feel at home is to treat yourself to the good stuff.

3. When’s the best time to visit these spots?

Weekday mornings are great if you want to skip the crowds, especially at Zabar’s and Hungarian Pastry Shop. Dinner hours can get busy at spots like Mama’s Too and Sala Thai, so plan ahead or order to go. But part of the charm is the buzz—lines here often mean you’re in the right place.

4. Do any of these have outdoor seating or are good for hanging out?

Hungarian Pastry Shop has lovely outdoor seating when the weather’s nice—great for people-watching or reading. Kikoo Sushi and Sala Thai also offer a relaxed atmosphere for dine-in. Most of the delis and carts are grab-and-go, but there are plenty of nearby parks and benches for enjoying your meal.

5. What if I’m not on the UWS—can I still try any of these places?

Yes! Several of these spots have locations across the city—Broadnosh, Sala Thai, and Zabar’s all have expanded reach. But if you can make it to the Upper West Side, it’s worth the visit. The vibe here adds to the flavor, truly.

Leave a Comment