You found our guide to the Best Places to Grab a Pizza Slice Near NoMad!

There’s something distinctly satisfying about finding the perfect slice in a city that invented the genre. If you’re seeking the best places to grab a slice of New York pizza near NoMad, the choices are as refined and memorable as the neighborhood itself. For those who prioritize wellness and self-care, balance is key—and sometimes that means enjoying a really good slice. In a world of green juices and infrared saunas, there’s still space for indulgence that feels intentional, joyful, and delicious.

Looking for more NYC food recommendations? Check out our guide to Eating Like a Local for a Day in the East Village!

This article includes:

Pizza spots near NoMad
New York style pizza Midtown
Best pizza places in NYC
Italian restaurants near NoMad
Pizza delivery places near me

Let’s get into it!

Best Places to Grab a Slice of New York Pizza near NoMad

1. Scarr’s Pizza – Classic, Elevated

Though located slightly south of NoMad, Scarr’s is worth the extra few blocks. This Lower East Side staple now offers delivery and quick access from Midtown. Known for its vintage vibes and stone-milled flour dough, it’s a health-forward nod to nostalgia. The crust? Thin, with a delicate chew and impeccable flavor. Ingredients are local and organic where possible. Their classic cheese slice is light, clean, and deeply satisfying—perfect for an indulgence that feels balanced.

Check out Scarr’s Pizza.

2. $1.50 Fresh Pizza – Classic NYC, No Fuss

Formerly known as 99¢ Fresh Pizza, this West 40th Street staple delivers exactly what the name promises: a hot, satisfying slice for just $1.50. It’s the quintessential New York pizza experience—quick, flavorful, and no-frills. The crust is thin, the sauce is tangy, and the cheese has just the right stretch. There’s no pretense here, just a solid, reliable slice that’s been feeding busy New Yorkers for decades. For those who value quality and convenience without complication, $1.50 Fresh hits the spot. Sometimes, balance means treating yourself to something simple—and really good.

Visit $1.50 Fresh Pizza’s West 4oth Location.

3. Joe’s Pizza – Iconic Without Compromise

The Flatiron outpost of Joe’s Pizza is steps from the NoMad border. For decades, Joe’s has defined what a New York slice should be. The balance of tangy sauce, gooey cheese, and crisp crust is just right—never too greasy, always reliable. It’s the go-to for women who appreciate timeless quality. No modifications necessary.

Learn more about Joe’s Pizza 1453 Broadway Location.

4. Rubirosa – A Sit-Down Spin on the Slice

This Nolita gem makes its way into many NoMad day plans thanks to its popularity with delivery and reservations. Rubirosa’s thin-crust pies are legendary, with vodka sauce and gluten-free options that don’t compromise on texture. Perfect for a lunch date, a casual client meeting, or a solo self-care moment with a glass of sparkling water and something truly comforting.

Check out Rubirosa.

5. Mama’s Too! – Bold, Beautiful, and Worth the Walk

Just south of NoMad in the West Village, Mama’s Too! offers thick, square slices with a cult following. These aren’t your standard grandma slices—each piece is a mosaic of high-quality ingredients and bold design. The pepperoni slice, with its crispy cup edges and layer of aged mozzarella, is pure satisfaction. For those who want a slice that feels decadent, different, and perfectly designed, this spot delivers. Bonus: it travels well for a nearby park lunch or cozy solo moment back at home.

Visit Mama’s TOO! West Village.

6. Vezzo – Cozy, Crisp, and Underrated

Tucked along Lexington, Vezzo is a hidden gem. With its low lighting and intimate seating, it’s a calm space in a busy part of town. The slices are ultra-thin and ideal for sharing (or not). There’s a quiet elegance in its simplicity—perfect for an impromptu lunch that still feels intentional.

Check out Vezzo.

7. Song’ E Napule – Authentic Neapolitan Near NoMad

While technically in the West Village, Song’ E Napule delivers across Manhattan and is beloved by Italian expats and discerning locals alike. Neapolitan-style pizzas arrive with blistered crusts, imported San Marzano tomatoes, and fresh bufala mozzarella. Great for nights when comfort food and high standards go hand in hand.

Learn more about Song E’ Napule on Houston.

Final Thoughts

NoMad sits at the crossroads of culture, style, and elevated convenience—and its pizza offerings reflect exactly that. Whether you’re walking from a gallery opening, finishing a skincare facial, or simply enjoying a solo moment of indulgence, these curated pizza spots strike the balance between everyday ease and refined satisfaction. In a neighborhood where wellness and self-expression go hand in hand, pizza isn’t just a guilty pleasure—it’s a choice made beautifully, with intention and joy.

Enjoyed this article? Next, check out 15 Things to Do in SoHo: The Perfect Itinerary.

more from sundays:

FAQ: Best Places to Grab a Slice of New York Pizza near NoMad

1. Are there any upscale pizza restaurants in NoMad?

While Marta is temporarily closed, Rubirosa and Song’ E Napule offer refined experiences that elevate traditional pizza dining.

2. Is there gluten-free pizza available near NoMad?

Yes, Rubirosa offers an outstanding gluten-free crust that doesn’t sacrifice taste or texture, and delivers to the NoMad area.

3. What pizza spots near NoMad offer vegetarian-friendly options?

Rubirosa, Scarr’s, and Mama’s Too! all offer standout vegetarian slices, from vodka sauce pies to seasonal veggie toppings, without compromising flavor.

4. Are there pizza places near NoMad with outdoor seating?

While options change seasonally, Rubirosa and some locations of Joe’s offer limited sidewalk seating when weather allows—perfect for a sunny afternoon slice.

5. Is there a pizza place near NoMad that feels comfortable for solo dining?

Vezzo’s cozy interior makes it a calm, easy place to dine solo, as does the counter setup at Joe’s. Both are inviting without being too busy or overwhelming.