You found our guide to how to choose the right red nail polish—a timeless color with endless possibilities. From bold cherry reds to deep wine hues, red polish can elevate any look when chosen thoughtfully. This guide will help you discover your perfect shade of red, whether you’re aiming for something fun and playful, elegant and refined, or bold and powerful.

This list includes:

• choosing red nail polish
• perfect red nail polish
• red nail polish guide
• red polish selection

These how to choose the right red nail polish are similar to Picking the Perfect Nail Color for Your Skin Tone and Undertones.

Let’s get to it!

How Do I Choose the Right Red Nail Color for Me?

Choosing the right red nail polish depends on a few key things: your skin tone, your undertone, the occasion, and your personal style. The right shade should complement your complexion and bring out your natural glow rather than clash or overpower.

For a quick cheat sheet:

• Fair skin tones: try cool cherry reds or classic true reds

• Medium skin tones: opt for orange-based reds, corals, or brick reds

• Olive or tan skin tones: go for cranberry or rust tones

• Deep skin tones: bold burgundies, plums, and oxblood reds work beautifully

Knowing your undertone can also help (more on that below). But don’t be afraid to experiment—confidence is the best polish of all.

What Makes Red Nail Polish So Classic?

Red polish has been iconic for decades because it’s powerful, sensual, and versatile. It works just as well at a black-tie gala as it does on a casual weekend brunch. It carries connotations of glamour, passion, strength, and confidence.

From Old Hollywood bombshells to minimalist fashion icons, red has remained a staple in beauty. Whether glossy and glamorous or deep and moody, there’s a red for every style, making it the ultimate classic.

How Does Color Theory Work?

Color theory plays a big role in what makes a red shade feel right. It’s not just about the polish—you’re also balancing how it plays with your skin’s natural hues.

Here’s a quick breakdown:

• Warm reds (with orange or yellow undertones) pop on warmer skin tones.

• Cool reds (with blue or pink undertones) flatter cooler skin tones.

• Neutral reds (balanced undertones) are versatile and suit most complexions.

Understanding this basic principle helps narrow down your search and ensures a red polish that enhances rather than distracts.

Why Trust Us?

At sundays, we believe beauty should feel like self-care—not guesswork. Our non-toxic, 10-free polishes are created with both performance and wellness in mind. We’ve helped thousands of clients find their perfect shades at our NYC studios, and we’re excited to share the insights that make red polish selection simple and satisfying.

How to Choose the Right Red Nail Polish

Whether you’re browsing for your signature red, a seasonal update, or the perfect polish for an upcoming event, understanding how to select the right shade is essential. Let’s dive into the factors that matter most.

1. Understand Skin Tone

Your skin tone is the surface color of your skin—fair, light, medium, tan, or deep. Certain reds will naturally look more harmonious with different tones. A vivid cherry red may brighten fair skin, while rich oxblood complements deeper tones beautifully.

When you know your skin tone, you can begin to curate a palette of reds that flatter effortlessly.

2. Check Your Undertones

Beyond skin tone, your undertone is the hidden hue beneath the surface—cool, warm, or neutral. You can check yours by looking at the veins on your wrist:

• Blue or purple veins = cool undertones

• Greenish veins = warm undertones

• A mix of both = neutral

For cool undertones, try blue-based reds like crimson or raspberry. Warm undertones shine in tomato reds and corals. Neutral undertones can explore across the red spectrum.

3. Consider Occasion & Season

Where you wear your red polish matters. Just like clothing, certain shades feel more suited to different seasons and events.

• For work or formal events: choose sophisticated shades like garnet or wine

• For summer or vacations: lean into brighter reds and corals

• For winter and holidays: go bold with deep reds, plums, or shimmer finishes

Let your nail polish reflect your mood, season, and setting.

4. Test Durability

A gorgeous red that chips in a day? Not ideal. Before committing to a shade, test how long it lasts. Durability depends on the formula, finish, and how it’s applied. Look for long-wearing, non-toxic formulas that stand up to your daily routine without compromising health.

At sundays, our polishes are tested in-studio by real clients—so you know they’re made to last.

5. Explore Finishes

Finish can change the mood of a red instantly:

• Glossy: classic, shiny, and polished

• Matte: modern, edgy, and unexpected

• Metallic: reflective, glam, and statement-making

• Glitter: festive, fun, and bold

Trying different finishes is a simple way to keep your red feeling fresh, even if you stay loyal to a favorite hue.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

• Choosing red based only on the bottle color—it often looks different once applied.

• Ignoring your undertone (it makes a big difference!).

• Skipping base coat or top coat (they’re essential for wear and shine).

• Overlooking the finish—glossy vs matte can totally change the vibe.

Expert Tips for Choosing the Right Red Nail Polish

• Try before you commit. Paint a swatch on one nail or use press-ons to preview.

• Match red to your wardrobe accents for a cohesive look.

• Don’t fear bold shades—confidence is key.

• Seasonal reds can refresh your routine without a full polish overhaul.

• Keep nails healthy with nourishing treatments between manis.

Our Favorite Shades of Red

Here are some studio-favorite red shades our clients love:

• No.13 – A winner of the Allure Best of Beauty 2020 & 2021 Nail Polish Of The Year. Best for warm or neutral undertones—especially medium to deep skin. Its chili red warmth brings an energizing glow.

• No.15 – A bright and powerful red that’s energetically glam, you’ll want to create an unforgettable night. Flattering on all skin tones. Pops beautifully on medium to deep complexions with warm undertones. Bold, bright, and unforgettable.

• No.17 – A rich, deep red with subtle dark cherry undertones. Its cool undertone makes it especially flattering on those with cool or neutral undertones, enhancing natural depth without overpowering. On fair skin with cool undertones, it can create a striking, dramatic contrast that feels bold and elegant.

• No.18 – An elegant deep berry red that’ll warm you up during the colder seasons. Let this luscious shade flow gracefully on your nails, like a smooth and full-bodied glass of red wine. Best on cool-toned skin. Its berry wine hue adds elegance and warmth, especially in fall and winter.

• No. 19 – A dark velvet red with brown undertones, both contemporary and sophisticated. Beautiful on deep and olive skin with neutral or warm undertones. Its velvet brown-red adds depth and quiet drama.

• No.24 – A muted cream red combines with orange and dusty rose, bringing the beauty of a sunset to your nails. Flattering on medium to tan skin with warm or neutral undertones. The sunset-inspired hue adds warmth to cooler seasons.

• No. 25 – An earthy rose red that adds a natural feminine touch to everyday chic. Great for fair to medium skin with warm or neutral undertones. The earthy rose tone offers a soft, grounded elegance.

Check out our other shades of red polish.

Final Thoughts on How to Choose the Right Red Nail Polish

Choosing the right red is more than picking a polish—it’s a celebration of your personal style, energy, and essence. The perfect red can boost your confidence, complement your natural beauty, and bring a moment of joy to your day.

Whether you’re drawn to bright berries, romantic wines, or fiery corals, there’s a red out there that’s made for you.

Next, check out our posts on Pink Summer Nails: A Guide to sundays studio’s Most Loved Summer Nail Colors.